Move to end earlier approval deference could lead to more scrutiny, with Indian workers likely to be hit hardest

By Our Bureau
WASHINGTON:
A proposed change in U.S. immigration policy could make it more difficult for H-1B and L-1 workers to secure extensions, a move that is expected to affect Indian professionals the most, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) data.
The Department of Homeland Security has put forward a rule to end the practice of deferring to previous approvals when the same parties and facts are involved in H-1B and L-1 extension requests. The proposal, titled “Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility,” is open for public comments until November 13. It was published in the Federal Register on October 14 under DHS Docket No. USCIS-2026-0529, with submissions accepted only through regulations.gov.
Currently, 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) requires immigration officers to generally defer to an earlier approval in the same case, unless there is a material error, a significant change in circumstances or new adverse information. The proposed rule would remove this requirement and apply to all Form I-129 petitions, including those for H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and P workers.
The existing regulation would remain in place until a final rule is issued.
Key Figures at a Glance
- 399,000 – H-1B petitions approved by USCIS in fiscal 2024.
- 71% – Were for beneficiaries born in India.
- 79% – Of about 258,000 approvals for continuing employment went to Indian-born workers (approximately 203,000).
- 208,000 – Estimated petitions per year could be affected by the proposed rule.
- ~6,000 – Additional requests for evidence expected annually (about 3 percentage points increase).
Article – Continued
USCIS approved about 399,000 H-1B petitions in fiscal 2024, and 71 per cent were for beneficiaries born in India, the agency’s annual report to Congress said. Of the approximately 258,000 approvals for continuing employment — the category that includes extensions — nearly 203,000, or 79 per cent, went to Indian-born workers.
The Department of Homeland Security stated that H-1B petitions make up more than 75 per cent of all Form I-129 filings. It estimated that the rule could affect around 208,000 petitions each year and that the rate of requests for evidence could rise by about 3 percentage points, or roughly 6,000 additional requests annually. Cases receiving such requests typically take 64 days longer to process, on average.
DHS said the current deference policy “effectively shifts the burden from the petitioner to the USCIS officer to justify departing from a prior approval.” The department cited site-visit data showing combined non-compliance and fraud at about 22 per cent of H-1B extension sites visited in fiscal 2022–2025, compared with about 17 per cent in fiscal 2018–2020, when deference was not in place.
While the rule would not prevent officers from considering a prior approval when relevant, DHS said it would remove the requirement that they begin with a position of deference.
The department also noted that employers and workers may have made career and personal plans in the U.S. based on the assumption that they could continue their employment and legal stay. The deference policy has changed several times — introduced in 2004, rescinded in 2017, reinstated in 2021 and later written into regulation in 2024.
Why the Change Matters
Experts say the proposal could increase processing times and uncertainty for skilled workers, especially those from India.
Immigration specialists believe the rule may lead to more scrutiny of extension requests, which could result in longer wait times and higher costs for employers and employees.
Given the large share of Indian nationals in the H-1B programme, the impact is expected to be felt most strongly in that community.
Featured Quote
“The proposal would not prohibit officers from considering a prior approval where relevant. Instead, it removes the requirement that they start from a position of deference to the earlier decision.”
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
What Happens Next?
Public has until November 13 to submit comments on the proposed rule.
The proposal is currently open for public feedback, and the final version will be decided after reviewing the comments. Until then, the existing deference rule remains in effect.
Industry observers say the outcome could have a significant bearing on the future of H-1B and L-1 workers, particularly those from India, who form the largest share of approved petitions.